Taiwanese anti-tobacco delegates blocked from joining the 17th WCTOH due to political interference from the WHO

Chih-Wen Kao, Mattia Sanna, Chih Kuan Lai, Chi Pang Wen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

We, registered NGO delegates from Taiwan to the 17th WCTOH in Cape Town, South Africa, were blocked from attending the World Conference. In addition, all peer-reviewed accepted scientific posters/presentations from Taiwan were first removed, and then some rescheduled to non official hours after protest. This undeserved treatment of the Taiwanese tobacco control delegates – non-governmental individuals who had, in good faith, paid not only the registration fee but the flights and accommodations in Cape Town – was due to political interference by the World Health Organization (WHO). We were told that the WHO, acceding to Chinese government demands, signed a sponsorship agreement with the International Union of Lung Diseases and Tuberculosis – the WCTOH secretariat – specifying that no participants from Taiwan should be allowed to attend the Conference. Taiwan is a successful democracy with a thriving economy and stands ready to contribute to and share its experiences with global tobacco control colleagues. In all previous WCTOH, Taiwan’s participation and contributions to the Conference were always welcomed by liberal democratic allies and the civil society.

We wish to express our anger for this unacceptable political interference at an important civil society event in global tobacco control. Blocking the legitimate Taiwanese delegates from the WCTOH, violates the guiding principles of the WHO FCTC which emphasize the special contribution of civil society and recognize the participation of NGOs as essential to achieve the objectives of the FCTC and to counter tobacco industry’s interference. Allowing WHO and authoritarian governments to dictate who can attend a civilian conference in tobacco control is a huge setback to democratic values, and to the right to health and full civic participation in global tobacco control. The WCTOH should be entirely civilian-oriented, free from political interference.

The independence of civil society has been compromised this time. We urge WHO and the WCTOH secretariat to commit to political neutrality regarding civil society’s participation at a NGO event. Episodes like this must not happen again. We believe that it is necessary to condemn this action, because when basic civil human rights are violated, nobody really wins as “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.” ― Martin Luther King Jr.
Original languageEnglish
JournalWHO Blog Tobacco Control
Publication statusPublished - Mar 9 2018

Fingerprint

WHO
nicotine
interference
civil society
Taiwan
non-governmental organization
participation
town
sponsorship
event
poster
neutrality
allies
anger
fee
accommodation
protest
flight
contagious disease
faith

Cite this

Taiwanese anti-tobacco delegates blocked from joining the 17th WCTOH due to political interference from the WHO. / Kao, Chih-Wen; Sanna, Mattia ; Lai, Chih Kuan; Wen, Chi Pang.

In: WHO Blog Tobacco Control, 09.03.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{c5716300b36b44f1b41599e8c4b974fc,
title = "Taiwanese anti-tobacco delegates blocked from joining the 17th WCTOH due to political interference from the WHO",
abstract = "We, registered NGO delegates from Taiwan to the 17th WCTOH in Cape Town, South Africa, were blocked from attending the World Conference. In addition, all peer-reviewed accepted scientific posters/presentations from Taiwan were first removed, and then some rescheduled to non official hours after protest. This undeserved treatment of the Taiwanese tobacco control delegates – non-governmental individuals who had, in good faith, paid not only the registration fee but the flights and accommodations in Cape Town – was due to political interference by the World Health Organization (WHO). We were told that the WHO, acceding to Chinese government demands, signed a sponsorship agreement with the International Union of Lung Diseases and Tuberculosis – the WCTOH secretariat – specifying that no participants from Taiwan should be allowed to attend the Conference. Taiwan is a successful democracy with a thriving economy and stands ready to contribute to and share its experiences with global tobacco control colleagues. In all previous WCTOH, Taiwan’s participation and contributions to the Conference were always welcomed by liberal democratic allies and the civil society.We wish to express our anger for this unacceptable political interference at an important civil society event in global tobacco control. Blocking the legitimate Taiwanese delegates from the WCTOH, violates the guiding principles of the WHO FCTC which emphasize the special contribution of civil society and recognize the participation of NGOs as essential to achieve the objectives of the FCTC and to counter tobacco industry’s interference. Allowing WHO and authoritarian governments to dictate who can attend a civilian conference in tobacco control is a huge setback to democratic values, and to the right to health and full civic participation in global tobacco control. The WCTOH should be entirely civilian-oriented, free from political interference.The independence of civil society has been compromised this time. We urge WHO and the WCTOH secretariat to commit to political neutrality regarding civil society’s participation at a NGO event. Episodes like this must not happen again. We believe that it is necessary to condemn this action, because when basic civil human rights are violated, nobody really wins as “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.” ― Martin Luther King Jr.",
author = "Chih-Wen Kao and Mattia Sanna and Lai, {Chih Kuan} and Wen, {Chi Pang}",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
day = "9",
language = "English",
journal = "WHO Blog Tobacco Control",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Taiwanese anti-tobacco delegates blocked from joining the 17th WCTOH due to political interference from the WHO

AU - Kao, Chih-Wen

AU - Sanna, Mattia

AU - Lai, Chih Kuan

AU - Wen, Chi Pang

PY - 2018/3/9

Y1 - 2018/3/9

N2 - We, registered NGO delegates from Taiwan to the 17th WCTOH in Cape Town, South Africa, were blocked from attending the World Conference. In addition, all peer-reviewed accepted scientific posters/presentations from Taiwan were first removed, and then some rescheduled to non official hours after protest. This undeserved treatment of the Taiwanese tobacco control delegates – non-governmental individuals who had, in good faith, paid not only the registration fee but the flights and accommodations in Cape Town – was due to political interference by the World Health Organization (WHO). We were told that the WHO, acceding to Chinese government demands, signed a sponsorship agreement with the International Union of Lung Diseases and Tuberculosis – the WCTOH secretariat – specifying that no participants from Taiwan should be allowed to attend the Conference. Taiwan is a successful democracy with a thriving economy and stands ready to contribute to and share its experiences with global tobacco control colleagues. In all previous WCTOH, Taiwan’s participation and contributions to the Conference were always welcomed by liberal democratic allies and the civil society.We wish to express our anger for this unacceptable political interference at an important civil society event in global tobacco control. Blocking the legitimate Taiwanese delegates from the WCTOH, violates the guiding principles of the WHO FCTC which emphasize the special contribution of civil society and recognize the participation of NGOs as essential to achieve the objectives of the FCTC and to counter tobacco industry’s interference. Allowing WHO and authoritarian governments to dictate who can attend a civilian conference in tobacco control is a huge setback to democratic values, and to the right to health and full civic participation in global tobacco control. The WCTOH should be entirely civilian-oriented, free from political interference.The independence of civil society has been compromised this time. We urge WHO and the WCTOH secretariat to commit to political neutrality regarding civil society’s participation at a NGO event. Episodes like this must not happen again. We believe that it is necessary to condemn this action, because when basic civil human rights are violated, nobody really wins as “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.” ― Martin Luther King Jr.

AB - We, registered NGO delegates from Taiwan to the 17th WCTOH in Cape Town, South Africa, were blocked from attending the World Conference. In addition, all peer-reviewed accepted scientific posters/presentations from Taiwan were first removed, and then some rescheduled to non official hours after protest. This undeserved treatment of the Taiwanese tobacco control delegates – non-governmental individuals who had, in good faith, paid not only the registration fee but the flights and accommodations in Cape Town – was due to political interference by the World Health Organization (WHO). We were told that the WHO, acceding to Chinese government demands, signed a sponsorship agreement with the International Union of Lung Diseases and Tuberculosis – the WCTOH secretariat – specifying that no participants from Taiwan should be allowed to attend the Conference. Taiwan is a successful democracy with a thriving economy and stands ready to contribute to and share its experiences with global tobacco control colleagues. In all previous WCTOH, Taiwan’s participation and contributions to the Conference were always welcomed by liberal democratic allies and the civil society.We wish to express our anger for this unacceptable political interference at an important civil society event in global tobacco control. Blocking the legitimate Taiwanese delegates from the WCTOH, violates the guiding principles of the WHO FCTC which emphasize the special contribution of civil society and recognize the participation of NGOs as essential to achieve the objectives of the FCTC and to counter tobacco industry’s interference. Allowing WHO and authoritarian governments to dictate who can attend a civilian conference in tobacco control is a huge setback to democratic values, and to the right to health and full civic participation in global tobacco control. The WCTOH should be entirely civilian-oriented, free from political interference.The independence of civil society has been compromised this time. We urge WHO and the WCTOH secretariat to commit to political neutrality regarding civil society’s participation at a NGO event. Episodes like this must not happen again. We believe that it is necessary to condemn this action, because when basic civil human rights are violated, nobody really wins as “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.” ― Martin Luther King Jr.

UR - http://blogs.bmj.com/tc/2018/03/09/taiwanese-anti-tobacco-delegates-blocked-from-joining-the-17th-wctoh-due-to-political-interference-from-the-who/

M3 - Article

JO - WHO Blog Tobacco Control

JF - WHO Blog Tobacco Control

ER -