A proposal to unify the classification of breast and prostate cancers based on the anatomic site of cancer origin and on long-term patient outcome

László Tabár, Peter B. Dean, Amy M F Yen, Miklós Tarján, Sherry Y H Chiu, Sam L S Chen, Jean C Y Fann, Tony H H Chen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The similarity between the structure and function of the breast and prostate has been known for a long time, but there are serious discrepancies in the terminology describing breast and prostate cancers. The use of the large, thick-section (3D) histology technique for both organs exposes the irratio-nality of the breast cancer terminology. Pathologists with expertise in diagnosing prostate cancer take the anatomic site of cancer origin into account when using the terms AAP (acinar adenocarcinoma of the prostate) and DAP (ductal adenocarcinoma of the prostate) to distinguish between the prostate cancers originating primarily from the fluid-producing acinar portion of the organ (AAP) and the tumors originating either purely from the larger ducts (DAP) or from both the acini and the main ducts combined (DAP and AAP). Long-term patient outcome is closely correlated with the terminology, because patients with DAP have a significantly poorer prognosis than patients with AAP.The current breast cancer terminology could be improved by modeling it after the method of classifying prostate cancer to reflect the anatomic site of breast cancer origin and the patient outcome. The long-term survival curves of our consecutive breast cancer cases collected since 1977 clearly show that the non-palpable, screen-detected breast cancers originating from the milk-producing acini have excellent prognosis, irrespective of their histologic malignancy grade or biomarkers. Correspondingly, the breast cancer subtypes of truly ductal origin have a significantly poorer outcome, despite recent improvements in diagnosis and therapy. The mammographic appearance of breast cancers reflects the underlying tissue structure. Addition of these "mammographic tumor features" to the currently used histologic phenotypes makes it possible to distinguish the breast cancer cases of ductal origin with a poor outcome, termed DAB (ductal adenocarcinoma of the breast), from the more easily managed breast cancers of acinar origin, termed AAB (acinar adenocarcinoma of the breast), which have a significantly better outcome. This simple and easily communicable terminology could lead to better communication between the diagnostic and therapeutic team members and result in more rational treatment planning for the benefit of their patients.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)15-38
Number of pages24
JournalBreast Cancer: Basic and Clinical Research
Volume8
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 25 2014

Fingerprint

Prostatic Neoplasms
Adenocarcinoma
Breast Neoplasms
Prostate
Terminology
Neoplasms
Breast
Histology
Milk
Therapeutics
Biomarkers
Communication
Phenotype
Survival

Keywords

  • Acinar adenocarcinoma of the breast (AAB)
  • Breast cancer terminology
  • Ductal adenocarcinoma of the breast (DAB)
  • Neoductgenesis
  • Prostate cancer terminology
  • Subgross 3-D histology

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Cancer Research
  • Oncology

Cite this

A proposal to unify the classification of breast and prostate cancers based on the anatomic site of cancer origin and on long-term patient outcome. / Tabár, László; Dean, Peter B.; Yen, Amy M F; Tarján, Miklós; Chiu, Sherry Y H; Chen, Sam L S; Fann, Jean C Y; Chen, Tony H H.

In: Breast Cancer: Basic and Clinical Research, Vol. 8, No. 1, 25.02.2014, p. 15-38.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Tabár, László ; Dean, Peter B. ; Yen, Amy M F ; Tarján, Miklós ; Chiu, Sherry Y H ; Chen, Sam L S ; Fann, Jean C Y ; Chen, Tony H H. / A proposal to unify the classification of breast and prostate cancers based on the anatomic site of cancer origin and on long-term patient outcome. In: Breast Cancer: Basic and Clinical Research. 2014 ; Vol. 8, No. 1. pp. 15-38.
@article{ebaa38e5ad804bd49e3b1a99124aa508,
title = "A proposal to unify the classification of breast and prostate cancers based on the anatomic site of cancer origin and on long-term patient outcome",
abstract = "The similarity between the structure and function of the breast and prostate has been known for a long time, but there are serious discrepancies in the terminology describing breast and prostate cancers. The use of the large, thick-section (3D) histology technique for both organs exposes the irratio-nality of the breast cancer terminology. Pathologists with expertise in diagnosing prostate cancer take the anatomic site of cancer origin into account when using the terms AAP (acinar adenocarcinoma of the prostate) and DAP (ductal adenocarcinoma of the prostate) to distinguish between the prostate cancers originating primarily from the fluid-producing acinar portion of the organ (AAP) and the tumors originating either purely from the larger ducts (DAP) or from both the acini and the main ducts combined (DAP and AAP). Long-term patient outcome is closely correlated with the terminology, because patients with DAP have a significantly poorer prognosis than patients with AAP.The current breast cancer terminology could be improved by modeling it after the method of classifying prostate cancer to reflect the anatomic site of breast cancer origin and the patient outcome. The long-term survival curves of our consecutive breast cancer cases collected since 1977 clearly show that the non-palpable, screen-detected breast cancers originating from the milk-producing acini have excellent prognosis, irrespective of their histologic malignancy grade or biomarkers. Correspondingly, the breast cancer subtypes of truly ductal origin have a significantly poorer outcome, despite recent improvements in diagnosis and therapy. The mammographic appearance of breast cancers reflects the underlying tissue structure. Addition of these {"}mammographic tumor features{"} to the currently used histologic phenotypes makes it possible to distinguish the breast cancer cases of ductal origin with a poor outcome, termed DAB (ductal adenocarcinoma of the breast), from the more easily managed breast cancers of acinar origin, termed AAB (acinar adenocarcinoma of the breast), which have a significantly better outcome. This simple and easily communicable terminology could lead to better communication between the diagnostic and therapeutic team members and result in more rational treatment planning for the benefit of their patients.",
keywords = "Acinar adenocarcinoma of the breast (AAB), Breast cancer terminology, Ductal adenocarcinoma of the breast (DAB), Neoductgenesis, Prostate cancer terminology, Subgross 3-D histology",
author = "L{\'a}szl{\'o} Tab{\'a}r and Dean, {Peter B.} and Yen, {Amy M F} and Mikl{\'o}s Tarj{\'a}n and Chiu, {Sherry Y H} and Chen, {Sam L S} and Fann, {Jean C Y} and Chen, {Tony H H}",
year = "2014",
month = "2",
day = "25",
doi = "10.4137/BCBCR.S13833",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "15--38",
journal = "Breast Cancer: Basic and Clinical Research",
issn = "1178-2234",
publisher = "Libertas Academica Ltd.",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A proposal to unify the classification of breast and prostate cancers based on the anatomic site of cancer origin and on long-term patient outcome

AU - Tabár, László

AU - Dean, Peter B.

AU - Yen, Amy M F

AU - Tarján, Miklós

AU - Chiu, Sherry Y H

AU - Chen, Sam L S

AU - Fann, Jean C Y

AU - Chen, Tony H H

PY - 2014/2/25

Y1 - 2014/2/25

N2 - The similarity between the structure and function of the breast and prostate has been known for a long time, but there are serious discrepancies in the terminology describing breast and prostate cancers. The use of the large, thick-section (3D) histology technique for both organs exposes the irratio-nality of the breast cancer terminology. Pathologists with expertise in diagnosing prostate cancer take the anatomic site of cancer origin into account when using the terms AAP (acinar adenocarcinoma of the prostate) and DAP (ductal adenocarcinoma of the prostate) to distinguish between the prostate cancers originating primarily from the fluid-producing acinar portion of the organ (AAP) and the tumors originating either purely from the larger ducts (DAP) or from both the acini and the main ducts combined (DAP and AAP). Long-term patient outcome is closely correlated with the terminology, because patients with DAP have a significantly poorer prognosis than patients with AAP.The current breast cancer terminology could be improved by modeling it after the method of classifying prostate cancer to reflect the anatomic site of breast cancer origin and the patient outcome. The long-term survival curves of our consecutive breast cancer cases collected since 1977 clearly show that the non-palpable, screen-detected breast cancers originating from the milk-producing acini have excellent prognosis, irrespective of their histologic malignancy grade or biomarkers. Correspondingly, the breast cancer subtypes of truly ductal origin have a significantly poorer outcome, despite recent improvements in diagnosis and therapy. The mammographic appearance of breast cancers reflects the underlying tissue structure. Addition of these "mammographic tumor features" to the currently used histologic phenotypes makes it possible to distinguish the breast cancer cases of ductal origin with a poor outcome, termed DAB (ductal adenocarcinoma of the breast), from the more easily managed breast cancers of acinar origin, termed AAB (acinar adenocarcinoma of the breast), which have a significantly better outcome. This simple and easily communicable terminology could lead to better communication between the diagnostic and therapeutic team members and result in more rational treatment planning for the benefit of their patients.

AB - The similarity between the structure and function of the breast and prostate has been known for a long time, but there are serious discrepancies in the terminology describing breast and prostate cancers. The use of the large, thick-section (3D) histology technique for both organs exposes the irratio-nality of the breast cancer terminology. Pathologists with expertise in diagnosing prostate cancer take the anatomic site of cancer origin into account when using the terms AAP (acinar adenocarcinoma of the prostate) and DAP (ductal adenocarcinoma of the prostate) to distinguish between the prostate cancers originating primarily from the fluid-producing acinar portion of the organ (AAP) and the tumors originating either purely from the larger ducts (DAP) or from both the acini and the main ducts combined (DAP and AAP). Long-term patient outcome is closely correlated with the terminology, because patients with DAP have a significantly poorer prognosis than patients with AAP.The current breast cancer terminology could be improved by modeling it after the method of classifying prostate cancer to reflect the anatomic site of breast cancer origin and the patient outcome. The long-term survival curves of our consecutive breast cancer cases collected since 1977 clearly show that the non-palpable, screen-detected breast cancers originating from the milk-producing acini have excellent prognosis, irrespective of their histologic malignancy grade or biomarkers. Correspondingly, the breast cancer subtypes of truly ductal origin have a significantly poorer outcome, despite recent improvements in diagnosis and therapy. The mammographic appearance of breast cancers reflects the underlying tissue structure. Addition of these "mammographic tumor features" to the currently used histologic phenotypes makes it possible to distinguish the breast cancer cases of ductal origin with a poor outcome, termed DAB (ductal adenocarcinoma of the breast), from the more easily managed breast cancers of acinar origin, termed AAB (acinar adenocarcinoma of the breast), which have a significantly better outcome. This simple and easily communicable terminology could lead to better communication between the diagnostic and therapeutic team members and result in more rational treatment planning for the benefit of their patients.

KW - Acinar adenocarcinoma of the breast (AAB)

KW - Breast cancer terminology

KW - Ductal adenocarcinoma of the breast (DAB)

KW - Neoductgenesis

KW - Prostate cancer terminology

KW - Subgross 3-D histology

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84896886998&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84896886998&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.4137/BCBCR.S13833

DO - 10.4137/BCBCR.S13833

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84896886998

VL - 8

SP - 15

EP - 38

JO - Breast Cancer: Basic and Clinical Research

JF - Breast Cancer: Basic and Clinical Research

SN - 1178-2234

IS - 1

ER -